The habitat requirements of the loggerhead shrike suggest a long interrelationship with extinct Pleistocene megafauna. Shrikes prefer grazed grasslands with nearby thickets of short trees for nesting and isolated taller trees for perching. A cow pasture adjacent to a large yard landscaped with trees and bushes is ideal habitat for a shrike. Shrikes use the isolated trees as observation posts where they search for prey. A grazed pasture maintains just the right height of grass so a shrike can find their favorite foods–grasshoppers, mice, lizards, small snakes, and other song birds. Grass that gets too tall could also conceal a predator such as a fox or cat not averse to making a meal of shrike. Thickets provide good places for shrikes to hide their nests. During the Pleistocene mammoths, bison, and horses maintained the range of habitats required by shrikes, the haphazard mix of grazed pasture, isolated tall trees, and thickets. Despite the unlikelihood that a predatory songbird could become preserved in the fossil record, shrike remains dating to the Pleistocene have been excavated from 2 fossil sites in Florida at Arredondo and Reddick. Shrikes were probably common in the southeast for millions of years, and they surely witnessed herds of megafauna stirring up prey. The ancestor of the loggerhead shrike diverged from a Holarctic population of northern shrikes (Lanius excubitor) when Ice Ages began occurring, and glaciers isolated the founding population.
A great gray shrike with a mouse it impaled. They kill their prey by snipping the spine behind the head. Their claws are too weak to hold on to their prey when feeding and tearing with their bill, so they impale them on thorns or barbed wire.
Following the extinction of the megafauna, shrikes remained common in the southeast. Fire and Native American agricultural practices maintained favorable shrike habitat. The characteristics of sand hills with widely spaced pines, scrubby thickets, and sparse ground cover were always a preferred habitat for shrikes. When William Bartram traveled through the Florida sand hills in 1776 he noted that shrikes (or butcher birds as he called them), along with rufous-sided towhees and Florida scrub jays, were “very numerous.” He described this landscape as an open pine and palm savannah interspersed with thickets of magnolia, dwarf oaks, devilwood, blueberry, pawpaw, and buckthorn. In 1939 John May wrote in his classic A Natural History of North American Birds “The Loggerhead Shrike is an extremely common bird along the roadsides of Florida, where in winter every third or fourth telephone pole seems to serve as an outlook point for either a Mockingbird, a Sparrow Hawk, or a Loggerhead Shrike.”
Unfortunately, loggerhead shrike populations have drastically declined over the past 60 years. I’ve never seen one. A century ago, before the adoption of the car, horse pastures were abundant across the southeast. Farmers still raised cattle on all this excess pastureland for decades after cars replaced horse and buggies. Cotton and corn fields left fallow covered much of the south as well. Fallow fields rank 2nd to pasture as good shrike habitat. Much of this favorable shrike habitat has been converted to pine plantations, a type of environment that supports no wildlife. This ecological disaster also explains declines in the populations of eastern meadowlarks, vesper sparrows, grasshopper sparrows, and bobwhite quail. In Louisiana and Texas the conversion of cow pastures to rice plantations has caused a decline in shrike populations there. Invasive fire ants colonize the bare earth left after the rice is harvested, and they compete for the same prey items.
Shrikes are permanent residents in the south. Shrikes that breed in the Midwest migrate south during the winter. These migratory populations are suffering an even worse decline. Territorial shrikes that permanently reside in the south drive away migratory pairs from the remaining suitable habitat. Migratory shrikes have become extirpated from many areas where they formerly ranged. One study of shrikes in the North Carolina sand hills region determined that shrikes are disappearing from the periphery of their range, but core populations living in good shrike habitat are stable. I hope they remain so. The loggerhead shrike is on my birding wish list.
Lynn, Nadine; and Stanley Temple
“Land Use Changes in the Gulf Coast Region: Links to Decline in Midwestern Shrike Population”
The Passenger Pigeon 1991
“Breeding Distribution and Population Persistence of Loggerhead Shrikes in a Portion of the North Carolina Sandhills”
The Southeastern Naturalist 4 (14) 2015